News and Discoveries.

Recent Posts

Followers

October 30, 2021

Frank McCarroll, Cowboy, Actor, Stuntman


Frank appeared in at least 190 westerns and 10 serials. After leaving the family farm he started out with dual careers as a rodeo performer and a pro wrestler. 

On the rodeo circuit Frank specialized in steer wrestling (bulldogging). Frank was often champ or won second or third place money. His many championships included first place finishes at the 1916 and 1931 Pendleton, Oregon Roundup.

Frank married Mary Ellen 'Bonnie' Treadwell (1892-1929) who was also a rodeo performer and they married in 1914 in Boise, Idaho which became their home base. Bonnie was critically injured while ridding the bronc 'Black Cat' at the 1929 Pendleton event and passed away about ten days later.  Bonnie was the subject of the famous photo (below) which has sometimes been associated with her death which is incorrect and was taken earlier in her career.

In the early 1930's Frank married Lorris 'Lorrie' Schiller/ Schuller and shortly after started a new career in movies. He worked most often in B westerns, portraying gang members as well as doing extensive stunt work and doubling. He freelanced anywhere and everywhere. 

He has appeared in movies with such legendary actors as, John Wayne, Gary Cooper, Gene Autry, Jimmy Stewart, Allan Lane, Roy Rogers, Buster Crabb, Clark Gable, Lucille Ball and many, many more. 

Inducted into the National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum Rodeo Hall of Fame in 2007. In May 2012, the Pendleton Round-Up and Happy Canyon Hall of Fame also inducted Frank McCarroll into their Hall of Fame.

Frank was a 1st cousin three times removed from my maternal side of the family.

October 29, 2021

The Murder of Captain Longmuir


 Captain James Riach Longmuir was the husband of Helen Ord and master of the clipper Rifleman sometime before 1867 until his death in 1872.  On the 28th of December 1872 the Rifleman left London for Australia.  Captain Longmuir had expected the steward of the previous voyage to return with him, but was disappointed, and almost at the last moment reluctantly, we believe, engaged a German, of whose antecedents he had no means of obtaining information.  The new Steward of the vessel signed his name as William Krauss, he was also known as William Cross.

The sworn detailed account, as set forth in the ship's log, is substantially as follows: - On March 16, in lat.31.35 south, long. 34 west., the chief officer, Mr Morgan, had the middle watch, and about 4:30 am the steward brought him a cup of coffee, which he drank, and then walking aft to the compass was told by the helmsman that the crew thought something had been wrong with their grog, as all hands had been vomitting the day before.

Mr Morgan had been thinking over the matter, when the steward came on deck and said that Captain Longmuir wanted him.  He, of course, went below, the steward following.

When he got to the Captain's cabin, he called out "do you want me, Sir" and almost immediately received a violent blow over the left temple.  Although partially stunned, he turned round, and as he did so, received a second blow.

Seeing it was the Steward, he immediately closed with him and got his arms around him.  In the struggle, he got the steward against the foot of the captains berth, calling on the boatswain for assistance, who 

immediately rushed in and assisted in holding the steward's hands.  But, unwittingly, he let go , when the steward immediately drew a revolver, and firing at the boatswain, drove the bullet into his neck.

Mr Morgan seeing the boatswain falling, and thinking him killed, attempted again to secure the steward's hands, and at length got him fast by the wrists, and threw him on the cabin deck, but not before he had time to fire a second shot, which, barely missing Mr Morgan's head, buried itself in one of the beams.  Mr Newton, the second officer, hearing calls for help and the discharge of firearms, ran into the cabin with the rest of the watch, and after some difficulty, the steward was disarmed.

Dreading the worst, a light was procured, and on removing the coverlet a fearful sight met their eyes.  There lay Captain Longmuir, with his head beaten in, and quite dead, and the mattress, bedding, and berth deluged in blood.

He had evidently never struggled, but must have died from the effects of a single blow, or perhaps accelerated by strangulation, as a piece of log line was round the unfortunate man's throat, and drawn quite tight.  Krauss, on being searched, was found to have a second pistol (single barrel) concealed on him, also a dagger and long knife and 24 cartridges; and on the floor of the captain's room an iron channel bolt was picked up, about two feet long, and weighing 5 lbs.- doubtless the fatal instrument used, as the mark of the bolt head is on the beam over the berth as if it had been caused by raising the bolt too high.

Five pieces of line of similar description and length were also found in the steward's berth.  The Captain's body was put in spirits, and has been brought on to Sidney.  Krauss, after being well secured, was placed in the deck-house, and on his arrival was taken on shore by the water police.

He denies any knowledge of the crimes which have been committed.  An inquest was held and he was tried on a charge of wilful murder.  It must have been a foregone conclusion that he was guilty - and he was hung at Darlinghurst Jail and buried at Haslam Creek, Sydney.

Captain Longmuir had been a frequent visitor to Sidney and captained some of the finest ships.  It was reported in newspapers at the time that he was a most kind-hearted genial man, and respected by all who knew him.  On hearing of his death, all the ships in harbour flew their flags at half-mast as a sign of respect.

At the time of his murder, his wife Helen and their children, the youngest just 5 years old, were living in Old Machar.  By 1881, son Hugh was mate of the George Thompson, daughter Christine was a music teacher, John and James were seamen, Alex a shipping clerk, and Helen, the youngest, was still at school.

Captain Longmuir's wife Helen Ord was a 3rd cousin 4 times removed from my paternal side of the family.  Captain Longmuir's mother-in-law, Anne McWillie, was a cousin of George the diarist, who can also be found in our family tree.

Sources: The Aberdeen Morning Herald, 13 Aug 1873, Ann Marr No. 4399

October 28, 2021

The Rape and Murder of Ann Milroy


 

Anna Milroy was born on Valentine's Day in 1927 to Helen and Lester Milroy.  A little analysis and speculation suggests that Ann was named for her fathers younger sister Ann who died in 1911 at the age of 15 when Lester was 12.  Three other daughters in that family died young, at ages 2, 20 and 23.

Anna Milroy was working on the farm of Dan Cronin, Jr. in the summer of 1943 anticipating her junior year at Sutton High.  She came to town that Saturday evening and was with her sister Wilma and friend Barbara Carl. The girls stopped at the Yost Service Station for gasoline when Anna excused


herself to go to the restroom. When she did not return, Wilma and Barbara searched the station but did not find her. They guessed that Anna had found another way home but when they discovered she was not at home on Sunday, they sounded the alarm.


It was not until noon on Monday that Ray Carlson discovered Anna’s nude, battered body in a ditch south of Sutton. A chisel had been driven into her skull. Contemporary accounts placed the location of the body as eighteen miles south of Sutton, but reliable memories put the site as much closer, just a couple of miles south of town.

Late that afternoon a blood-spattered car was seen parked in Sutton. State Sheriff Lloyd Mengel arrested Private Joseph MacAvoy, a soldier at Harvard Army Airfield who was out on bond after attacking a woman in Hastings. MacAvoy had recently been demoted from Sergeant to Private in Army disciplinary action.

MacAvoy signed a detailed confession by 5:30 Tuesday morning in which he admitted meeting Anna at the gas station claiming she had accompanied him willingly and they had gone for a ride in the country. At some point things went wrong between the two. He denied raping Anna but evidence supported that charge. He admitted striking the girl with a crank and dumping her body before returning to Harvard.


Officials charged that he had returned to the body on Sunday and may have found her still alive and then drove the chisel into her head. He never confessed to that part of the charge. County Attorney S. W. Moger filed charges of first degree murder and murder in the perpetration of a rape. MacAvoy’s attorneys and his mother attempted to prove that injuries he had suffered as a youth in Brooklyn had contributed to his behavior.

Joseph MacAvoy was convicted of first degree murder on December 11th after only 75 minutes of deliberation by the jury. He was sentenced to die in the electric chair on December 30.

Here the story takes an odd twist. The Nebraska electric chair had not been used since 1929 and had fallen into disrepair. Details are blurred but apparently the source of parts to fix the chair was the U.S. Army and someone in that bureaucracy determined that the army was busy with other business in 1943 and that conducting a world war took priority over a Nebraska execution. (Seems reasonable.)

All obstacles were overcome by early 1945 and Wardon Neil Olson conducted the execution of Joseph Thomas MacAvoy on the morning of March 23, 1945.

The murder of Anna Milroy is the huge blot on the relationship between Sutton and the nearby military installations during World War II. There were probably a number of other occasions when local citizens found valid cause to regret the presence of the nearby army and navy installations but World War II brought the military world into the heart of U.S. live as most other conflicts have not.


A very sad story.  Remembering Anna, a 6th cousin twice removed from my maternal side of the family.

Goodale Family Murder, Suicide


 After many years of researching family history you're bound to find a few tragedies in the family. Some of the stories are disturbing and I won't go into great detail for those. The first story takes place in England in 1899.

In Twickenham, Middlesex, England on a Saturday morning the 11th of March 1899 Herbert (or Henry) Goodale, who carried on the business of a monumental stonemason, let his workmen in as usual at 6 am and according to some of his men there was nothing unusual in his appearance and he did not appear to be suffering from any excitement.

After many years of researching family history you're bound to find a few skeletons in the family closet.  Some of the stories were very disturbing and I won't go into great detail for those.  The first story takes place in England in 1899.

In Twickenham, Middlesex, England on a Saturday morning the 11th of March 1899 Herbert (or Henry) Goodale, who carried on the business of a monumental stonemason, let his workmen in as usual at 6 am and according to some of his men there was nothing unusual in his appearance and he did not appear to be suffering from any excitement. 

It is presumed that after letting the men in he went direct to his bedroom where his wife and two children, aged three years and four weeks were asleep.  He attacked his wife first and according to the evidence there was a struggle as in addition to her throat being cut, her arms were gashed, the bed-clothes were all scattered about the room, and the walls and floor were covered with blood.  He next went to his two children, cut their throats, and then cut his own, standing in front of the bedroom mirror.

The strange thing is that while all this was taking place inside the workmen outside were going on with their work as usual and did not hear anything.  Mr. James Goodale the father of Herbert, lives next door and went to see his son between 7 and 8 am.  Not getting any answer after knocking repeatedly he became concerned and, retrieved a ladder, climbed to the bedroom window where he saw the entire family lying dead in the room.  He immediately sent for the police and a doctor.  The doctor pronounced all four dead.  The murderer who was about 36 years of age had lived all his life in Twickenham and was highly regarded.  He was a teetotaler, took a prominent role in Church affairs, and was greatly loved by his workmen, one of whom stated that they could not have had a better master.  One of the workmen says that his master had lately been much worried with business matters, he having undertaken more work than he could handle and that he stated that he would have to give up some of it.

Mr. James Goodale, the father, says he has no doubt that his son’s mind had become unhinged through the effects of influenza, from which he suffered not long since, while another relative informed the press that as soon as he heard of the crime he put it down to religious mania, as for a long time Herbert Goodale, in his opinion, had been somewhat peculiar in the manner.

Source: The London Times.  13th March 1899

During my research of the Goodale family I came across this story a few times and skipped it thinking it must be another family.  Then I happened to notice, faintly written in a census return was a reference to this very family.  It turns out that Herbert Goodale was a 2nd cousin three times removed from my paternal side.  His children Rose and George were my 3rd cousins twice removed.